Like this article? rabble is reader-supported journalism. Chip in to hold studies like these coming.
we're suggested now not to choose a publication by using its cover. You can not recognize the cost of what is on the inner quite simply with the aid of outward look. Yet with Mona Awad's 13 methods of a fats woman, the title, if not the cowl, says plenty.
It expresses excess and insecurity. Thirteen is a bakers' dozen, one other than the common 12, brought to insure in opposition t gadgets now not being of statutory weight. The verb "appear" is padded, awkward, no longer at ease in its personal flesh. it be now not "to examine," a slimmer and extra based manner of phrasing it, but "of looking at." lastly, it refers to a woman, not a younger girl, which the website established Feminism assures us is sexist as hell.
And so we have a booklet foretold via its cowl: its contents are playful, structurally and rhetorically artful, mammoth, and slyly feminist. As Toril Moi writes in Sexual Textual Politics, "anger is not the handiest revolutionary perspective obtainable to us. The vigor of laughter can also be simply as subversive." And 13 ways has humour -- and irony -- in abundance.
simply put, 13 ways is 13 interconnected vignettes about Lizzie/Beth/Elizabeth/Liz, growing old gradually from about 14 to 30-some thing years, a girl who struggles with her weight and her personal, and others', belief of it. it be crammed with the playfulness foreshadowed via the title and by the games Lizzie and her best friend Mel play within the first chapter, "once we Went towards the Universe."
The younger Lizzie becomes a self-pleasurable prophesy: "afterward i go to be in reality fucking captivating. i'm going to grow into that nose and strengthen an eating sickness. i'll be hungry and irritated all my life however i could also have a hell of a time." What Lizzie tells herself, apart from being hilarious and ironic, is something many, if no longer all, girls can relate to: the desire to conform to beauty norms even to the detriment of our fitness.
one of the vital many references to pop tradition are variations on the identify Elizabeth or the word "fat." Her mom has Liz Taylor hair. Beth tortures her weight-reduction plan self by using taking a look at images of Bettie web page, the Queen of Pinups. One persona thinks Lizzie has Betty Boop eyes. missing the shy Beth clad in dark black outfits that he fell in love with however has been replaced via a pared down Elizabeth in tight-becoming clothes "too hungry or irritated or distracted for intercourse," Tom drinks fats Tire beer.
The writing is conversational in tone and Lizzie/Beth/Elizabeth/Liz's inner speak and friendships with women -- the love, loathing, need and contradictory emotions expressed -- are flawless. here is decent, meaty writing.
but the bones are decent too, for now not best is there an specific "fat lady" in the booklet, one whose physique shrinks the more she becomes subordinated inside patriarchal vigour members of the family, however there's a structural fat girl as well.
there may be a point to make earlier than we proceed. the first is that while women may internalize the requirements of patriarchal society, these power relations don't seem to be simple. there may be extra about the desire for self-handle and the pressures women region on themselves to shed extra pounds than there is ready pressure from male characters.
truly, Elizabeth's better half would not desire her to alternate. That Elizabeth's father feels that her being fats is a call to be rebellious is an illustration of patriarchal pressure at work. fat, if the physique as an inscriptive surface,1 is libidinous and uncontrollable. skinny is decorous. Complicating concerns extra is that it's subsequently her mother who, in her satisfaction at Elizabeth's new slim body, objectifies her most through dressing her up and showing her off.
Many feminist literary theorists (right here i am thinking above all of Elizabeth Grosz and Judith Butler2) write persuasively of an implicit, classical affiliation of materiality with femininity, maternity and the corporeal, an affiliation that can also be traced returned etymologically to link depend with mater and matrix.
In Literary fats women and the generation of the textual content, Patricia Parker suggests how fats girls are used to make a text greater copious, to dilate it, and to defer its conclusion. while Parker writes peculiarly of Renaissance texts, this is a video game that you could play at domestic while observing motion pictures or paying attention to tune. Rhetorical fat ladies appear pretty commonly in movie and song.
I locate myself taking part in it with 13 techniques: which one of those vignettes is the additional one, the thirteenth in the bakers' dozen, the rhetorical fats woman?
in the beginning I selected "Your greatest Fan" as the story whose function is to lengthen the textual content. it be written in the 2d person ("you"), a notoriously tricky and strange voice to write down in. In it, Lizzie is explicitly known as "the fat girl." Or is it "She'll Do the rest," the best different story in the e-book that isn't written in first adult and which includes a lusty "fat chick." probably it's "If it truly is All there's" where "two fats girls in stretch pants are screaming and strangling each other" on a silent television in a health center waiting room.
I change my intellect a couple of times before I choose the one within the very center: "My mom's conception of sexy." Her mother is described as being fat to the aspect of ill fitness. notwithstanding it's anything they do not discuss, she has difficulty respiratory and might't think her feet. The chapter is crammed with images of water, essentially the most archetypally female of the points, and in it Beth is planning to flow away to the "gigantic pink wilderness" of the Southwest (away from the sea). it's the chapter that focuses on the mother/daughter relationship.
After this chapter, Elizabeth's thinness becomes downright damaging. a further feminist literary theorist, Julia Kristeva, would say that this manner of separation, faraway from the mom, results in abjection, despite the fact Kristeva speaks of it in psycholinguistic phrases in preference to literary ones.
The final words of the e-book are telling: "I suppose dangerously near an information it really is doubtless already ours for the taking, an information that i know might trade every little thing." That skills, these reports indicate, is that all the dieting and endeavor will not make us satisfied.
There needs to be some acceptance of fat and, eventually, of womanhood. change must start in our mother/daughter relationships and in particular person relationships between girls.
after all, they "Went in opposition t the Universe" as teenagers. perhaps she and her pals can achieve this again.
Mona Awad gained Amazon.ca's First Novel Award in may additionally 2016, a prize genuinely-earned during this reviewer's opinion.
Sarah Hipworth is co-editor of let them reside: U.S. war Resisters in Canada, 2004-2016, launched by using Iguana Books in may 2016.
1 Elizabeth Grosz, "The physique as Inscriptive surface," volatile our bodies: towards a Corporeal Feminism (Bloomington: Indiana UP, 1994)
2 Judith Butler, "our bodies that rely," bodies that count number (big apple: Routledge, 1993)
